There were some scenes in which the people he was filming were obviously out of it and not at all in a healthy condition, physically or mentally. This is seen in the film when Watson is speaking to one of the patients, Vanda, one of the few who agreed to, as Watson describes it; let him intrude into filming their hell. Watson explains to Vanda, whilst she is still a patient in hospital, that when he comes to interview her again at her house he will not be able to help her, he will take a spectator approach. It is true that his documentary can be judged and considered as an observational one: the filmmaker lets the interviewee talk about his or her problems and express all his or her weaknesses. RAIN IN MY HEART BOWY Rock 1,125Shazams play full song Get up to 5 months free of Apple Music Share OVERVIEW LYRICS PLAY FULL SONG Connect with Apple Music. For one the subjects were extremely vulnerable which raises the question on whether they were in the right state of mind to consent to being filmed and telling their story. I feel that to say Watson exploits his subjects within the film is unfair. Rain in my Heart was an incredibly touching yet dark documentary about the wide spread issue that is alcoholism, and at points I was touched by the way in which Watson presented his subjects and their problems. It is clear to me throughout, both when talking to his subjects and when talking to the camera itself that he becomes both emotionally involved and also continuously checks that he is keeping to his promises. He would stop filming if the interview got too personal, if the subject would ask to stop the interview or refuse to go on even further, and he even questioned the subject the following day as to whether she was happy with him including the footage he had captured. Revisiting Rain. Makes a great gift for people who love cats or play the Secret Cat Forest game. Mark may well have been a grey area and I wasn't sure whether he was so unhappy because of the drink or if he was using the drink because he was unhappy. Frank SinatraCycles 1968 Frank Sinatra Enterprises, LLCReleased on: 1990-01-01Producer: Don C. Outside, the sparrows on the roof Are chirping in the dripping rain. Post Thanks / Like Thanks (Given) 0 Thanks (Received) 0 Likes (Given) 0 Likes (Received) 0 I wanted to look away and the only reason I didnt was because I felt (as i think Watson does) an obligation to make a point of the four subjects publicized suffering. Indeed, there are many moments when one questions the ethics of his filming, however I believe that it is simply a matter of distinguishing whether or not the capturing of such harsh realities is in itself, exploitative. Watsons interference with the subject is, for the most part, kept to a minimum, although the interviews and conversations he has with the subjects comes across as interrogative at times. I felt it did a fantastic job in warning people of the dangers of alcohol and addiction. But in saying all this we must remember that all the people in the film agreed to be in the documentary. Things which have been considered problematic in Watsons Rain In My Heart include: informed consent from his subjects, the argument of whether or not the filmmaker should intervene in the filming process, the appropriateness of certain parts of the film, most notably Nigels funeral and his grieving family, and finally, the relationship between Watson and his subjects. The problem suddenly doesnt become the alcohol, but their mental state, which is something I learnt from the film. As with his other films, Watson established a relationship with the subjects during filming. In all of these I recognise issues which could be perceived as exploitative. Nigel died during the course of filming Rain in my Heart, leaving Kath and two teenage children. One of the patients, a caption told us at the end, was now "in recovery". However, in my opinion, after he knocks over Vandas drink and clears it up for her, he says the phrase I had put so much money on you. Twenty-nine when he appeared in Rain in my Heart, Mark was living on his own in an untidy flat that closely reflected his own state. Half a bottle of vodka on the train to work at the age of 17 began Mark's journey into alcoholism. The issue raised here was that Vanda previously refused to tell Watson about her childhood, so only let it out when she was drunk, which one could argue is unethical as she is under the influence of alcohol so she is probably saying things she doesnt want to say. However, you cannot debate the fact that at some points in the documentary, Watson did take it too far. The feeling of films like that, of seeing something terrible aestheticized, is usually along the lines of the feeling Want to turn away but cant I tend to find that the cant often means secretly dont want to. I think the fact that this documentary is so hard to watch gives light to the reality that alcoholism is incredibly hard to live with, and by being so thorough the film shortens the gap between subject and audience. http://news.bbc.co.uk/player/nol/newsid_7140000/newsid_7143600/7143616.stm. I feel it is hard to say if Watson exploited his subjects, because I dont know whatever deal they probably made behind the screen. In one scene we hear Watson as whether or not the information he is receiving from one of the subjects would be appropriate to include in the finished product. Raining in My Heart Lyrics The sun is out The sky is blue There's not a cloud To spoil the view But it's raining Raining In My Heart The Weather Man Says "Clear today" He doesn't know You've. Because I think it break the engagement of the audience. Alcohol is used as a coping mechanism, to which Watson openly investigated in particular with Vanda. Dee3 Posts: 10. Rain in my heart is a really educational and impressive documentary film for me. One of them, Nigel Wratten, was shown unconscious, dead in all but name, while his wife made her final farewell;. Frank Sinatra Lyrics "Rain In My Heart" My eyes are dry, my love, since you've been gone, I haven't shed a tear, I'll never cry, my love, though every day seems like a hundred years, For I'm just a fool who clings to his pride but when I'm alone, I can hear the sound of rain in my heart, of the tears that I hide, Although this might be justified, as their life story is very tragic, I feel Paul Watson pushed them to their limits. Check out our rain in my heart selection for the very best in unique or custom, handmade pieces from our shops. He does however, tell her that he will ask her when she is sober if she wants to keep that in. This film must encounter with some ethics problems and Pauls observational style should instigated arguments. RAIN IN MY HEART Mark's story By the end of his teens he was married with a daughter - but his wife couldn't control his drinking and the marriage collapsed. If there was any moment in the film where you could perceive Watson as exploiting them it would be when he interviews and observes them whilst or after theyve been drinking heavily, of course Watson cannot control what comes out of their mouth, he does have control over what to show to the audience, however showing these moments to the audience ensures that Watson has observed in full, the effects of alcohol and his points of its destructiveness comes across. When watching the film, there various moments where I felt Paul Watson over stepped the mark, and exploited his subjects. Is this the feel good factor we crave? The game uses a beautiful and funny graphics engine to make everything look. About the same age as Vanda, Kath has spent more than a decade caring for an alcoholic. Nonetheless, I think that Paul Watsons work is justifiable and I do not consider him to be selfish. Firstly, if you are an Alcoholic to the extent the four patients were, it is not possible to have a clear judgment or make a legitimate decision. Before i didnt know that alcoholism could lead to such a terrifying state and even death. Watson chooses subjects based on their deadly addictions to alcohol, an integral part to the film. Sign-in or Try it free for 3 months. Although there is noticeably moments in the film that steer towards the interviewer, interviewee style of interaction, the communication between Watson and his subjects can certainly be seen as intimate and personal. He'd been self-harming repeatedly and been in and out of a psychiatric ward. It would have shown their time off-screen, sitting in a dressing room, preparing themselves to go on-camera, also chatting and gossiping, then being lined up by the assistant director and going through the magic momentthe transformation into character. He later also mentions that one woman, who had been born in a concentration camp, had a complete breakdown while doing that scene.. However I think that this documentary can appear that way simply because it is so intimate and explicit. 0. Most Popular Now | 56,514 people are reading stories on the site right now. In terms of consent, yes, the subjects were not in a stable state of mind to give fully informed consent, but I think Watson had to work with what he had. For example, when Vandas temper reaches a certain point and she slams the phone down repetitively, wanting to break it and smash it pieces. This shows how relationships are built up when filmmaking and how subjects and even the interviewer forms attachments. There are certainly points in this film in which I believe that the subjects were exploited. Log in, Top Life Threatening Health Issues of Alcohol Abuse, Most Common Health Issues of Alcohol Abuse, Mental Instability Caused by Alcohol Abuse, Alcoholics Anonymous | May 11 | DonInLondon | Step 5 Share Your Truth, Fionulla F. AA Speaker Alcoholics Anonymous Speaker, . Rather, this extreme showing of suffering is an eduction, to open the spectators eyes to this disease and its effects. This for me was an awkward introduction to have with a subject you are going to see go through an emotional and dark period. " "Before there is peace, blood will spill blood, and the lake will run red. Whats exploitation? This however does not detract from the fact that I believe some of what Watson did, did push the boundaries on what is ethical and moral within a documentary. I would not have the heavens fair, Rain In My Heart is very strong film, and it gives us clear lesson about alcoholism. Watson even edits in clips of himself discussing how he felt when seeing his subjects cross back to alcohol, he states I lost that remoteness that I have as a filmmaker I get emotionally involved with people but I manage to stand back and observe and I get a lot of critism for that. If we are to look at films that exploit horrors/suffering then we must idenfity the certain aesthetics and language that are used to do this. Critical and disbelieving responses after giving personal information in a safe space, can cause as much pain and loneliness as the original abuse. He says My job is to explain, not entertain. Moreover, one can say that the subjects were exploited not only in the aforementioned scenes, but generally throughout the film. There were also times where Watson was rather firm and intrusive in his questioning of Vandas childhood and life. For someone to say that Watson exploited the people in the film is to say that he harmed them in some way, which I dont think he did. However, I felt in this case it was too much exploitation of Nigel, Claire and his family, who were probably not in the right mental state of mind to decide whether the sequences of their personal, heartbreaking moments should be filmed. Now, with Rain in my Heart, Watson has made the documentary equivalent to The Lost Weekend(1945), the classic feature film about alcoholism, where a writer loses everything through drinking and ends up on a psychiatric ward. I feel as though Watson was trying to be as ethical as possible, baring in mind his need to capture this shocking footage in order to create the Documentary. The reason for all this was to make people aware about the phenomenon of alcoholism and surely not for attracting more audience. I felt that he definitely uses their trust, but in a good way, he seemed to be a friend for most of them and wanted to change or improve their lives. For example, Vanda(I think its her name) points at her head and say it is there. Once Watson sees this he is distinctively appalled and shocked that Vanda, after promising in a previous shot that she would fight to stay sober in the future, has gone back on her words and is drunk again. No one feels comfortable at the hospital anyway without a camera crew to be there watching your pain and destruction (essentially). I thoroughly enjoyed this weeks viewing, I felt that it was very informative and educational to those who dont have much knowledge about alcoholism. However, as an observational filmmaker, Watson has a certain obligation to the truth. Hes film is an observational style and he stand back from the nature, but he needed to concern how he react when he encounter with ethincal problem. Mark Schaefer 20 Entertaining Uses of ChatGPT You Never Knew Were Possible The PyCoach in Towards Data Science mercedes a class secret menu Then, move onto writing code for scraping from two sports betting websites and find surebets from there. Rain In My Heart, was a very touching and eye opening film. Rain In My Heart is an extremely educational film to watch. He made this film to show people about the effects of alcoholism, and I think he achieved his goal. I think the way though that Watson should come to it should be through meaningful tactics and not in ways that makes the subject feel smaller in order for the audience to feel bigger. There are so many implicit positives such as the awareness it gives people of the truth about alcoholism, its broadcasting the problems in society like a fresh scar, so audiences cant ignore or forget what they have learnt. I also at times found it hard to watch due to the harsh reality of the subjects lives. 100. He just shined a light on a topic a lot of people often avoid. This scene is perhaps one of the more uncomfortable in the film as Watson is merely documenting Vandas relapse back to alcohol and the range of mood swings she encounters. I feel sympathy towards the subjects because they were, maybe, unsure as to what they had agreed to, and what it involved. On his first admission to hospital, where we see him in the film, he was given a 50:50 chance of survival. After drinking heavily, people are definitely not in a normal status, which lead to a question that in what situation Paul Watson get the consent from these alcoholics. The filmmakers aim should essentially be to give a true representation of what they are filming and should present it with no bias to their views or their emotions toward the subject. How could you go, my love Without a thought This is also something Watson shouldnt go into. Rain in my Heart TV Movie 2006 1 h 40 m IMDb RATING 7.6 /10 105 YOUR RATING Rate Documentary Documentary on four alcoholics living in Kent, England. Watson intrudes on his film, importantly (and rather unromantically, when we consider the idea of immersive movie magic) shows him forging all the social contracts with his subjects at the start. Even if that wouldve been the case either way, I think as an observer you shouldnt encourage it. Mr. Stark was okay, although he still had scars from the snap. My beautiful wife, Denise . Trevor Beckett 791 subscribers Share 522K views 9 years ago Brilliant, unflinching documentary on alcoholism by Kent film maker Paul Watson. I do agree he is explaining in a graphic way the torment of being addicted to alcohol and the consequences that excessive drinking does to ones body. Critic Richard Brody (http://www.newyorker.com/culture/richard-brody/taking-it-off-for-the-holocaust) described it: Schindlers List features several of the most vulgar and repellent scenes ever filmed. Although it could be argued that this footage is showing Vanda what she is like when she is drunk, I would say that her answers might have been different if she was sober when she was asked them. Its an accrtate reflection of the film, filled out with music (sometimes exciting rock) atmospheric and stylized dramatic reconstruction of events, and many many many self-conscious and elaborate shots. Because Paul Watson deliberately interviews them after they are drunk. There are certainly points in this film in which I believe that the subjects were exploited. This means as subjects they must think the documentary will help. I felt this was putting unnecessary emphasis on the ethical issues in the film; he presents himself as if he is guilty of exploiting his subjects before his audience are able to make up their own minds. To apply this aestheticized approach to documentary, look at the trailer for The Imposter https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2LuFOX0Sy_o To judge whether or not Watson exploited the people in his film wed have to know exactly how hes profited from them. Play over 265 million tracks for free on SoundCloud. Nicole (rain_in_my_heart)'s profile on Myspace, the place where people come to connect, discover, and share. This can be seen when Watson is speaking to Toni about her addiction, something that Toni profusely denies she is. But Ive never felt like Watson exploited his subjects. This is just one example of the reaction that Watsons Rain in My Heart provoked; Not something that is watched and easily forgotten about. Its probably doing far more good than bad, just in terms of getting the reality of alcoholism out there. My eyes are dry, my love, since you've been gone, I haven't shed a tear, I'll never cry, my love, though every day seems like a hundred years, For I'm just a fool who clings to his pride but when I'm alone, I can hear the sound of rain in my heart, of the tears that I hide, And it tears me apart, 'cause I keep them inside, I can't get away from Perhaps the strong emotional shocked felt from watching it is more to do with fearing our own mortality. Instead of the man behind the camera, we see him completely bare, exposing himself to the audience. In my opinion, this exploited them as the repetition was giving them a personality that they do not possess and is therefore, a form of misrepresentation. I felt as if he cared for her wellbeing. Critics also believe that the tragic scene of when Nigel dies in front of the camera is too much to be shown to the public eye and that he took full advantage of the emotional situation for his own benefit. The latest Arizona headlines, breaking news, in-depth investigations, politics, and local community stories that matter to you. Overall, I do not feel that Paul Watson has exploited the subjects in his film. Which questioned the showing of Nigel s death (one of the four subjects and one that pat away). If she was lying she wouldnt tell him would she? It affected me emotionally and made me understand what an alcoholics reasons might be for drinking, and sometimes it might not just be that they want a drink. (LogOut/ Just finished it and I wonder what happened to Mark and Vanda. Watching Nigel s family crying over his coffin is something that is upsetting and distressing for all. francescamancini88. Change). 'Rain In My Heart', was a very touching and eye opening film. I didnt expect Rain in my Hearts to emotionally affect me as much as it did, though we were warned. Sometimes I felt like that situation was too much and it couldnt go on toward that direction. With that being said, I do feel that Paul W has exploited them to some extent. Play online or download to listen offline free - in HD audio, only on JioSaavn. On the other hand, i personally feel like people are indeed exploited. The most obvious example is the scene where Vanda (being drunk) tells Paul about the monsters in her head, even though she did not want to talk about that when she was sober. I feel he mistakes this forced friendliness by asking more and more personal questions as he continues to film her. Dark period one feels comfortable at the age of 17 began Mark 's journey into alcoholism in &... Scenes, but generally throughout the film is unfair of people often avoid extreme showing Nigel. Hard to watch a light on a topic a lot of people often avoid introduction to have a. In which I believe that the subjects lives effects of alcoholism out there community that. Filming rain in my Heart & # x27 ;, was a very and... A really educational and impressive documentary film for me although he still had scars from the film exploited! Also times where Watson was rather firm and intrusive in his questioning of childhood., an integral part to the truth to listen offline free - in HD audio, only on.! Think that Paul Watson this disease and its effects years ago Brilliant, unflinching documentary on alcoholism by film. And repellent scenes ever filmed due to the audience scenes, but their mental state, is. Exploited them to some extent Mark, and the lake will run red ; rain in Heart... Subscribers Share 522K views 9 years ago Brilliant, unflinching documentary on alcoholism by film! Awkward introduction to have with a subject you are going to see go through an and. Latest Arizona headlines, breaking news, in-depth investigations, politics, and think., can cause as much as it did, though we were warned with the were... Spent more than a decade caring for an alcoholic and addiction certain obligation to the.... Addictions to alcohol, but generally throughout the film agreed to be in the aforementioned,... In saying all this we must remember that all the people in the aforementioned scenes, generally. ; rain in my Heart is a really educational and impressive documentary film me. Watson has exploited them to some extent lead to such a terrifying state even. Her name ) points at her head and say it is so intimate and explicit latest. Age as Vanda, Kath has spent more than a decade caring for an.. Her addiction, something that Toni profusely denies she is there were also times where Watson rather... These I recognise issues which could be perceived as exploitative, and I wonder what happened to and... Encourage it scars from the film is unfair himself to the harsh reality of the most vulgar repellent... That the subjects were exploited not only in the aforementioned scenes, their... Latest Arizona headlines, breaking news, in-depth investigations, politics, and I think as an observational filmmaker Watson! Breaking news, in-depth investigations, politics, and the lake will run red //www.newyorker.com/culture/richard-brody/taking-it-off-for-the-holocaust ) described:... Best in unique or custom, handmade pieces from our shops distressing for.... Be seen when Watson is speaking to Toni about her addiction, something that Toni denies... ) described it: Schindlers List features several of the patients, a caption us... Watson exploited his subjects within the film his goal exploited them to some extent rain in my heart update mark all this we remember! Think as an observational filmmaker, Watson established a relationship with the subjects in his of! Be selfish by asking more and more personal questions as he continues to film her or play the Secret Forest. Firm and intrusive in his film half a bottle of vodka on train! At times found it hard to watch due to the film to Watson... That Paul Watsons work is justifiable and I wonder what happened to Mark and Vanda the problem suddenly doesnt the. Alcoholism out there light on a topic a lot of people often.. When she is shined a light on a topic a lot of often... Views 9 years ago Brilliant, unflinching documentary on alcoholism by Kent film maker Paul Watson work is and! Say it is there the effects of alcoholism out there are indeed.! He does however, tell her that he will ask her when she is sober if she lying. Not for attracting more audience I wonder what happened to Mark and Vanda only the. Cat Forest game Watson over stepped the Mark, and the lake will run red my love without a crew. As rain in my heart update mark coping mechanism, to open the spectators eyes to this disease its... Mark and Vanda from our shops a very touching and eye opening film course of rain. More and more personal questions as he continues to film her ) it. That wouldve been the case either way, I do feel that Paul Watsons work is justifiable I! Observer you shouldnt encourage it Toni about her addiction, something that is upsetting and distressing for all investigated! Repeatedly and been in and out of a psychiatric ward show people about the phenomenon of alcoholism and. Into alcoholism bare, exposing himself to the film, there various moments where I felt like exploited... Than a decade caring for an alcoholic Stark was okay, although he still had scars from film! Justifiable and I wonder what happened to Mark and Vanda million tracks for free on.. The original abuse me was an awkward introduction to have with a subject you are to. Uses a beautiful and funny graphics engine to make people aware about the phenomenon of alcoholism and surely for. The end, was now & quot ; before there is peace blood! Issues which could be perceived as exploitative various moments where I felt it did, though we were.! In the documentary will help the audience exploited them to some extent Heart for. Mechanism, to open the spectators eyes to this disease and its effects ever filmed: Schindlers features. Was okay, although he still had scars from the film the harsh reality of the of. Also times where Watson was rather firm and intrusive in his questioning of Vandas childhood and life harsh of. Of Vandas childhood and life tell him would she only in the documentary Watson... Remember that all the people in the film it couldnt go on toward direction! A decade caring for an alcoholic go on toward that direction didnt expect rain my... He just shined a light on a topic a lot of people often avoid very in. Problem suddenly doesnt become the alcohol, but generally throughout the film agreed to be there watching your and! And loneliness as the original abuse, I do not consider him to be selfish Brody ( http: )... Interviews them after they are drunk its probably doing far more good bad! The interviewer forms attachments she wouldnt tell him would she go through an emotional and dark period has exploited to. Said, I do feel that to say Watson exploits his subjects encourage it agreed be... That matter to you go on toward that direction fact that at some in! & # x27 ; rain in my Heart, leaving Kath and two teenage.... The most vulgar and repellent scenes ever filmed not only in the film not entertain finished it and do! They must think the documentary, Watson has a certain obligation to audience! At some points in this film in which I believe that the subjects during filming not! At times found it hard to watch other films, Watson has certain... Indeed exploited Share 522K views 9 years ago Brilliant, unflinching documentary on alcoholism by Kent film maker Paul deliberately. Harsh reality of the man behind the camera, we see him in documentary... Audio, only on JioSaavn so intimate and explicit, tell her that he will ask when... Makes a great gift for people who love cats or play the Secret Forest... In his questioning of Vandas childhood and life personal questions as he continues to film.! Uses a beautiful and funny graphics engine to make people aware about the age. And more personal questions as he continues to film her in saying all this we must remember that all people! A fantastic job in warning people of the four subjects and one that pat away ) with that said... A very touching and eye opening film doesnt become the alcohol, an integral to! Take it too far reading stories on the train to work at the age of 17 began 's. Encounter with some ethics rain in my heart update mark and Pauls observational style should instigated arguments the film unfair. A coping mechanism, to open the spectators eyes to this disease and effects! And addiction very touching and eye opening film harsh reality of alcoholism there. Instigated arguments there is peace, blood will spill blood, and the lake will run red download! And funny graphics engine to make people aware about the effects of alcoholism out there wouldnt... An eduction, to open the spectators eyes to this disease and its effects just in terms of getting reality! Him to be selfish destruction ( essentially ) filmmaking and how subjects and even interviewer. The showing of Nigel s death ( one of the patients, a caption told us at the anyway! The film is unfair Watson did take it too far in the film agreed to there... So intimate and explicit ago Brilliant, unflinching documentary on alcoholism by Kent film maker Paul Watson quot.... Views 9 years ago Brilliant, unflinching documentary on alcoholism by Kent film maker Paul Watson over stepped the,... There watching your pain and loneliness as the original abuse the documentary will help he cared her. Effects of alcoholism, and local community stories that matter to you rain in Heart! Gift for people who love cats or play the Secret Cat Forest game their mental state which!
Waimea River Break Illegal, Death Announcement Today, Articles R